Those are some pretty hard words you both throw out there. Dropping the SL Staff Member and looking at Aaron's article objectively, I think he has put together a very good list of candidates for Game of the Year as well as his sub-categories; somethig that's actually hard to do believe it or not.

As far as the Diablo II exp, I have to agree with Aaron's decisions. D2 could either fit in the RolePlaying or Multiplayer categories but even with that said, I still agree that it wouldn't win with the competition that he listed. The other games personally kept my interest well beyond playing the game the first time to the end. Would I pick D2 over Return to Castle Wolfenstein? What about Dark Age of Camelot or Max Payne? Nope.

I don't think this was a sad attempt at all to put together a review nor the opinions of a man who only spent a little time with each game. I am just sorry that you didn't enjoy our views but don't think it was fair of you to take this out on Aaron personally.

Don't get me wrong, I loved D2 ToB and had a really fun time playing it. If there was a category for expansion pack of the year, this would get my vote by far. But there wasn't.

BTW Aaron, it's time to get rid of our dartboard - they're on to us!